Our Everyday Menu
In The Mix Bakeshop Menu
**All products are prepared in a shared space; meaning gluten, gluten-free, nut, nut-free, dairy, and dairy-free products are made in the same space. While all appropriate steps are taken to keep all allergens separate, it is not always possible to eliminate every trace of the allergen.
Traditional Baked Goods
Cookies
$3.25
Muffins
$3.00
Brownies
$3.50
Bars
$3.50
Scones
$3.25
Cupcakes
$3.25
Bagels
$2.50
Croissants
$3.50
Filled Croissants
$3.75
Danish
$3.75
Turnovers
$3.75
Sin-A-Mon Rolls
$4.25
Croissockets
$5.50
Cheaper By The...
Cupcakes - 1 Dozen
$30
Cupcakes - 1/2 Dozen
$16
Cupcakes - 1 Dozen - GF/V
$33
Cupcakes - 1/2 Dozen - GF/V
$17
Muffins- 1/2 Dozen
$15
Muffins - 1/2 Dozen - GF/V
$17
Bagels - 1 Dozen
$25
Bagels - 1/2 Dozen
$13
Sin-A-Mon Rolls - 1 Dozen
$45
Sin-A-Mon Rolls - 1/2 Dozen
$24
Sin-A-Mon Rolls - 1 Dozen - GF
$48
Sin-A-Mon Rolls - 1/2 Dozen - GF
$26
Pastry Mix - 1/2 Dozen (croissant, turnover, danish)
$20
Gluten-Free
Cookies
$3.50
Muffins
$3.25
Brownies
$3.75
Bars
$3.75
Cupcakes
$3.50
Vegan
Cookies
$3.50
Muffins
$3.75
Cupcakes
$3.50
Brownies
$3.75
By The Slice
Cakes
$4.00
Cheesecake
$4.25
Quiche
$5.50
Pie
$3.50
Tea Cake
$5.50
Gluten Free - By The Slice
Cake
$4.00
Cheesecake
$4.25
Quiche
$5.50
Pie
$3.50
Tea Cake
$5.50
Ready-To-Go
Gluten Free and vegan options will have an additional charge
6" Cakes
$30
8" Cakes
$40
8" Cheesecakes
$35
8" Cookie Cakes
$25
10" Cookie Cakes
$35
9" Pies
$20
9" Quiche
$25
Tea Cakes
(1/4 Sheet)
$40
Granola
1 Pound
$10
Yogurt Parfait
$5
Drinks
Iced Coffee
12 oz
$2.50
20 oz.
$3.50
Iced tea
12 oz
$2.50
20 oz.
$3.50
Lemonade
12 oz
$2.50
20 oz.
$3.50
Coffee
12 oz
$2.50
20 oz.
$3.50
Tea
12 oz
$2.00
Milk
8 oz
$2.00
Delicious Goods
Custom Orders
Fill Out The Form
Confirm The Details
Eat Fresh-Baked Delciousness
Custom Cakes & Catering
Get In The Mix for any occasion:
Weddings * Birthdays * Anniversaries * Family Reunions * Corporate Events * Graduations * Baby Showers * Just Because *
Delicious Reviews
"These cookies are absolute perfection! The chocolate chips are generous and the cookies are soft and chewy.”
Ingrid B.
“Best chocolate chip cookies I've ever had, hands down."
Lilly F.
"The cookie box arrived beautifully packaged and the cookies were fresh and delicious”
Dean X.
"The chocolate chip cookies are the best I've ever tasted! The box arrived quickly and the cookies were fantastic”
Dean X.
Delicious food. Always.
We are excited to provide homemade goods that you can enjoy at any time of day, and at any occasion. Baked goods and great food bring people together, and we are happy to bring more joy to Plattsburgh and the surrounding area.
Stop-by today or place a special order for your next get-together.